Buy vs. Rent

Renting is for suckers

The real benefits of having a mortgage payment.

Every so often the media runs a story telling you renting beats owning. Usually it works by lining up two monthly payments side by side and declaring the smaller one the winner. That reasoning is flawed at its core, and it leaves out almost everything that actually matters.

One Benefit vs. Three

A mortgage does three jobs. Rent only does one.

I said this out loud at a recent presentation to first-time buyers. It is something I have always understood but rarely put into words. Rent gives you exactly one thing. A mortgage gives you three.

If you rent
1benefit
  • A place to live, for exactly as long as you keep sending the payment.
If you own
3benefits
  • A place to live, the same as renting.
  • The principal portion works like forced savings.
  • Deductions that often beat a renter's standard deduction.
Where the Money Goes

Two of those three benefits build real wealth.

The principal is money you pay to yourself

The principal portion of your payment builds equity. Think of it as moving money from one pocket to another, except the second pocket is your own home. Every payment chips away at what you owe and adds to what you own. Put that alongside the way property tends to appreciate over time, and you have a form of wealth building that renting simply cannot match. A renter watches the property go up in value and does not share in a dollar of it.

The mortgage can push you past the standard deduction

Here is where the interest really works in your favor. Most renters have very little to write off, so they take the standard deduction and stop there. Once you own, your mortgage interest, usually alongside your property taxes, tends to add up to more than that standard deduction. When it does, you itemize, and you get to deduct more than a renter ever could. A larger deduction means a lower taxable income and a smaller tax bill at the end of the year.

A quick example · married filing jointly, 2025
Mortgage interest$30,000
Property taxes+ $9,000
Your itemized deductions$39,000
Standard deduction a renter takes− $31,500
Extra deduction you get by owning$7,500

That $7,500 is a deduction a renter simply does not get, and it comes off your income before the tax is ever calculated. The numbers here are illustrative; your own figures and the year's deduction limits will differ, so check with a tax professional.

So who really comes out ahead?

Put it all together and the picture is hard to miss. When you rent, you hand every one of a mortgage's benefits to your landlord. The forced savings, the tax advantage, the appreciation on the property, all of it goes to the owner while you get the roof and nothing else. The property grows in value without you taking part in any of it.

Scott Lawson Branch Manager · Marin Mortgage Brokers

“Renting hands every benefit of a mortgage to your landlord while the property appreciates without you. Paying rent is for suckers.”

Scott Lawson · Branch Manager · NMLS #312312

Disclaimer. America's Home Loans Inc. DBA Marin Mortgage Brokers is a licensed independent mortgage brokerage (company NMLS #231434, CA DRE #01524386). Scott Lawson serves as Branch Manager (individual NMLS #312312, CA DRE #01895185). This article reflects the author's opinion and is provided for educational purposes only. It is not tax advice, financial advice, a commitment to lend, an offer of credit, or a guarantee of terms. Whether itemizing benefits you, and by how much, depends on your individual situation and current tax law. Standard deduction amounts and deduction limits change from year to year. Consult a qualified tax professional about your circumstances. All loans are subject to credit approval, income and asset verification, satisfactory appraisal, title review, and underwriting approval. Program guidelines and terms are subject to change without notice and vary by lender, occupancy, property type, and loan purpose. Not all applicants will qualify. Marin Mortgage Brokers is licensed to conduct business in California. Equal Housing Opportunity.